4/5 Fun for the whole family. Well, not really.
  by M. Braden
Not as funny as Wet Hot American Summer, but still worth watching, The State fans will love it.

1/5 Paul Rudd Used to = Comedy Gold
  by K. Johnson (Clemson, SC)
This is my first review, and I use Amazon reviews for 100% of the items I buy online so I try to head warnings when they are there.

If you see Paul Rudd on the cover of this DVD, do not associate it with anything else he has done. This movie is painfully bad. It may mock formulaic styles of movies (as one poster before mentioned), but none of the "jokes" click. The stories are boring and dull, which would be fine if they made you laugh. The only laughs you will have during this movie is the laughter from your friends when you remind them how much money you paid to own this DVD. Save your time, save your money.

5/5 Randomly Fantastic!
  by msmugler (SF, CA)
I ran across this movie on video on demand. My roomate and I laughed so hard we were crying. Our favorite is "thou shall not covet thy neighbor's wife," but they are all hysterical.

Disclaimer: If you are a religious fanatic, a homophobe, or a "sheep", you will not enjoy this movie. That is to say that if you like mainstream comedy, you will HATE this movie. If you like sick, twisted, but brilliant comedy, it will be right up your alley!

5/5 David Wain Doesn't Disappoint
  by Caroline Anderson (Houston TX)
David Wain, Ken Marino, and Paul Rudd do incredible work together. All three of their voices are very evident and if you're a fan of any of them, you'll like this.

You'll notice that people have a tendency to call it the worst movie they've ever seen, or rate it zero stars. The truth is the humor is so incredibly absurd that it won't appeal to everyone. If you go into it not wanting to like it, you probably won't.

I personally laughed the whole way. So has every audience I've seen it with. Some of the sketches are stronger than others (my personal favorite being any of the ones with Ken Marino's character, like Murder and Covet they neighbors wife) but I assure you if you keep an open mind, one of them will appeal to you.

1/5 Suckular at best
  by Lena
Luckily, my boyfriend picked this up in the $5 bin at a discount store. If he had spent anymore on this soon-to-be door stopper, I would be irate. I'd donate this to Goodwill, but it seems unfair for someone else to be duped into buying this suckular movie.

I've seen and enjoyed "Wet Hot American Summer," so I thought that this film from David Wain would deliver..nope. The final scene is an absurd musical recap of the disjointed sketches. The finale just didn't work. I thought for certain that this was originally a musical/play penned by the writers, and adapted unsuccessfully into a film--I wanted desperately to think that this was not the intended product. Nope.

Skip this movie. Charlton Heston's Moses made me laugh more than this wannabe religious satire. I wish I could get back the 96 minutes that I spent on this film and go to church instead.