5/5 FANTASTIC CLASSIC!
  by Texas Lou (Texas)
This fine movie is a must for any Classic collection! Interesting plot, snappy dialog and masterful performances by young actors, Robert Mitchum, Kirk Douglas, and Jane Greer. First rate supporting cast too, with Rhonda Fleming and a sappy Ann Huston (but she's supposed to be sappy!), child actor Dickie Moore and Paul Valentine as a menacing but almost-kind-hearted thug. To me, this is how movies are supposed to be made!

5/5 Exquisite Film Noir belongs on the Top Shelf
  by William R. Ray (Arden, NC USA)
The DVD transfer on this Warner Bros. release is very good. It's clear and looks good enough to represent the first screenings of this movie.

It's really hard to find a better film of this genre, even if you look to the more notable films of dark ilk like the "The Maltese Falcon" or "Chinatown". Robert Mitchum is excellent as the still idealistic PI who is hired for his honesty to find a mobster's girl. The mobster (Kirk Douglas) just wants the girl back, forget the 40 grand she took as she left. It doesn't make a lot of sense until you see our drop-dead gorgeous femme fatale (Jane Greer). Now you know why the mobster is willing to forget the money and hire someone outside his gangster buddies to find her. From that point, we fall into a whirlpool of intrigue, lust, betrayal and....oh yes, murder.

Have I mentioned the perfect ending? I won't tell. Some reviewers waste space with extended plat synopsis. I should have given you just enough information to bring you home. Buy this DVD, either as a single or better yet, with the Warner Bros. Video box set, "Film Noir Classic Collection" (volume 1). "Out of the Past" belongs on your top shelf and you can trust me on this one.

Highly Recommended to: Film noir fans, non-noir people who need to be converted and to all movie fans, regardless of situation.



5/5 Out of the Past
  by Harry Brewer (S'port, La.)
Out of the Past is classic film-noir. Why this film hasn't garnered more acclaim & fame I don't know. It's not quite an essential film but it's as close as a film can be to that distinction without garnering that claim. Jacques Tourneur, the director, helped to create the film-noir genre with this film.

Robert Mitchum portrays Jeff Bailey, an ex-private eye. He's now a gas station owner that's hiding from his past. This was Mitchum's first starring role that gave him top billing. He had already appeared in over 30 films in just four short years. Many of these films he was barely noticeable & hadn't gotten great reviews as an actor. Out of the Past would change his whole future as a leading man.

In contrast, Kirk Douglas (Whit Sterling), was only appearing in his third film. Douglas was already making ripples & would reach star status in a shorter journey than Mitchum.

Jane Greer (Kathie Moffett) was only appearing in her eighth film & would never have a role this good in her short career.

As in most films in the film-noir genre there's not really a good guy. The only way you can call Bailey the good guy is to compare him to Kathie & Whit, in this context Bailey IS the good guy. Bailey is trying to escape his past but circumstances prevent this. Joe Stefanos (Paul Valentine) has, by accident, discovered the whereabouts of Bailey. Stefanos is a henchman for Whit who has an old score to settle with Bailey. In flashback we learn that Sterling had once hired Bailey to find Kathie who was Sterling's girl & had stolen $40,000 in cash from him. Bailey finds her in Acapulco but instead of returning her he falls for her. If ever there was a black widow Kathie is it; not only did she steal $40,000 but she had shot Sterling. Kathie denies she took the money but Bailey later finds a bankbook with a $40,000 deposit.

When Sterling shows up in Acapulco Bailey denies ever finding Kathie. He has double-crossed Sterling wanting to keep her for himself. Not only that but he has crossed his P.I. partner on the money payed by Sterling. All this comes back to haunt him a few short years later. Sterling wants to see Bailey & hire him again to fix something for him. Bailey goes to Lake Tahoe reluctantly knowing that no good is going to come of it.

Sterling has a tax problem that comes to seven figures. He wants Bailey to get the papers from a lawyer, Lloyd Eels (Ken Niles). Smelling a rat, Bailey questions the motives of Sterling & why he can't do it himself. Then, suddenly, Kathie reenters the picture & is once again the girlfriend of Sterling. Bailey now has to face up to the fact that Sterling knows that he had crossed him years before.

Out of the Past is full of witty dialog & innuendos. Bailey knows he's in a frameup but he feels obligated to correct the past. The problem is he's really not much better than Sterling or Kathie. The film is full of plot twists & duplicity. Not the most complicated of films yet the viewer has to pay full attention to keep up with everything. In the end everyone has to pay for their lack of virtues.

The film is in good shape as is the audio. There are subtitles & a bonus audio track that's a commentary on the film. Out of the Past is one of the best examples of film-noir & should not be missed.

4/5 Greater Now Than Then
  by S. Paulson (Bay Area)
Out of the Past was ignored by Hollywood when it came out in 1947. Not one Academy nomination is hard to believe. It's far more appreciated now plus has solidified its status as one of the Top 5 Noir movies all-time.


Snappy dialog, wonderful use of shadows and incredible cinematography push this film into the upper echelon of must-see noir films. The plot is convoluted but Mitchum and Greer have enough incendiary chemistry to keep things interesting. For the record, the line is: A dame with a rod is like a guy with a knitting needle. (Steve Brodie as Jack Fisher)

Great use of locations in the Sierra Nevada. Bonus seeing a smoldering Rhonda Fleming as Meta Carson. Virginia Huston, Mitchum's goody girlfriend, is so milquetoast one can see why Robert Mitchum would be hot for Greer. She never looked better.




4/5 "If I have to I'm gonna die last"
  by Robert www.fogcityfog.com (San Francisco)
"Out of the Past" has all the biggies: money, murder, double crossing and then the inevitable revenge, and especially the femme fatale. The plot is tight and interesting but a little opaque at times. Essentially you see the plot through Mitchum's character, so things that aren't all that clear to him aren't all that clear to you, though the overall plot line hangs together well if you give the movie the benefit of the doubt on the characters' motivations.

The movie is also well acted, though that's easier when portraying strong guys who don't show much emotion, as all of the main male characters do (or don't). Mitchum's dry delivery serves him well and Douglas is all smiles and sociopathy as the gambler/nemesis. Douglas' gunsel is also well played: the quintessential second banana smart enough to get away with murder but who knows deep down, he's not smart enough to be #1. The femme fatale is a tougher role and Greer does well, though her motivations are never really clear: she's an odd mix of sentiment and sociopath, an independent risk taker and co-dependent victim.

The film is very noir, as a good film noir should be. All of the main characters screw up mightily and (SPOILER) in the end they all die for their mistakes. Even in the final shot of the movie the last great gesture is a hurtful lie told for a greater good. A perfect movie? No, but a good one both as a stand-alone flick and as an important milestone in film noir development.

I specialize in San Francisco noir movie and book reviews. Have a suggestion? Send it to me via my blog.