4/5 By your command...watch this remake!
  by Crystal Starr Light (Here)
So finally, a bajillion years after I read the novelization of the miniseries, Battlestar Galactica, I got around to watching the actual miniseries! So if you read my review of the book, you may find some similarities as, shock of all shocks, there isn't much difference of the two.
The Battlestar, Galactica, under the command of Commander Adama is about to be retired. Just as it is, the Cylons, machines created by humans that rebelled against their masters, return and nearly wipe out all humanity. Now, the remnants must band together and seek survival.
I enjoyed the original Battlestar Galactica books (haven't gotten around to watching the series yet) and was afraid that it might be ruined. No problems there! The reimagining is perfect--even if Starbuck and Boomer are girls. Instead of resenting the females Starbuck and Boomer, I enjoyed them, to see women in positions of power instead of the ubiquitous "companions" (Cassiopeia in old Battlestar or Inara of Firefly fame) or relations of the big boys. Other minor changes (names such as "Starbuck" and "Boomer" are now pilot call-signs, and Zee is killed in an accident some time ago instead of during the battle fit the story well.
The events in the new Battlestar are most definitely edge-of-your-seat material. I enjoyed the special effects, the camera moves, the sets...all are different from the original yet work. Also the cinematography reminds me of Firefly - The Complete Series, which is never a bad thing. Lastly, I love how the sounds in space are muted (yeah, I'm a science geek).
The characters felt real to me, particularly Commander Adama and President Laura Roslin. Both are thrust into leadership, and deal with it differently...and yet is it differently?
About the only thing I can pick on, is the sexual content (all implied, but it goes kinda heavy on at the beginning). But really, I became really involved, wanting to cry at times (I generally don't cry in movies).
So, for this great remake of a classic, I give 4. Probably could be a 5 star show, but I just didn't feel the oomf to give it 5. So a proud 4 stars for the ingenious reimaging, the great characters, action, and set.

Brought to you by:
*C.S. Light*

5/5 it has it all!!!
  by Magda C. Reyna (texas)
i am a late-comer to this series, couldn't imagine a revamping of the old BSG series. WAS I WRONG!! There is drama, comedy, sex, suspense, politics, set is a futuristic society, but oddly like the one we live in now. I have gone thru all seasons except the last 4.5 which will be released VERY SOON and i am anxiously waiting. Give this a try, you will get hooked!

5/5 Great opener to a wonderful series - want to address another reviewer's comment
  by K. Lee (Portland, Oregon)
Firstly and admittedly, I don't have anything innovative to contribute to the general consensus that the reimagined Battlestar Galactica is a generally wonderful sci-fi series that well worth watching and that this Mini-Series does its job of enticing the curious viewer into wanting to watch the entire series--as it did with the SciFi Channel executives who were undecided about a long-term series commitment with this show until they saw the Mini-Series.

However, I wanted to address Beth Custer's comment (Jan 24, 2009) regarding the availability of the Mini-Series in the Season One box set. She is correct that this Mini-Series and its accompanying audio commentary is included with the first season DVD set and thus for the casual viewer, purchase of the box set renders separate acquisition of this DVD superfluous. However, for the fanatical among us who pore over every special feature and "extra", I wanted to point out that Season One DVD set omits "The Lowdown" making-of featurette, included only with this stand-alone DVD. I own both the stand-alone Mini-Series and the Season One set, of which I am glad, as I find the featurette both entertaining and informative.

5/5 A Must Buy!
  by Boe Price (Texas)
This show appeals to so many more people than just sci-fi followers. It has something for everyone. Start with the pilot show for season one and I can allmost guarantee you will be hooked.

5/5 Best sci fi seies ever
  by Peter D. Walchli (Pewaukee, WI)
I was a bit leery about what the new Battlestar Galactica was going to be like; after the first few episodes of the original series, it turned into "Wagon Train to Peyton Place (or 90210, or The OC, depending on your generation).

This series is anything but a soap opera. It matches "LOST" for plot twists, the effects are better than anything else on TV, and the actors (especially Edward James Olmos) are excellent. Also, the reruns are more watchable than "Star Trek". I'm buying the whole series.