5/5 I actually bought it (REAL review)
  by R. NEILSON (Atlanta, GA, USA)
My Evangelion background:
I have been a fan of the series since I rented the weird "End of Evangelion" movie a couple of years ago. I rented the original DVDs (the 'Perfect' collection) from Netflix and watched every episode in Japanese+Subtitles and English. I have also seen "Death & Rebirth."

What THIS collection contains (hardware):
I purchased this collection from Amazon. The disks have an interesting textured label application. Nothing else is special about the physical items. Thin DVD containers, decent box, NO inserts AT ALL unless you include the promo page stuck to the back of the box.

What THIS collection contains (software):
Just the episodes and the director's cut versions of four episodes, nothing extra. No commentaries, no interviews, no guides, nothing. Well, it has some previews, but those do not count. To be clear, the director's cut and original versions of the four episodes are both here.

Detailed review:
I watched the first DVD and was amazed at the quality of the transfer. It had been a few months since I had seen the Netflix version, so I re-rented the first DVD to compare.
Yes, the picture quality is vastly superior to the old version. I never really noticed the frame shake before, but watching the original was like watching a crappy 60's western--almost every transition was marred by at least two or three frame shakes that cannot be ignored once the 'clean' one is seen. The images themselves are also much cleaner. The old version looks like a VCR tape by comparison.
The sound was also amazing. I prefer watching in orignal Japanese with English subtitles, so it was a great surprise to hear it in Dolby Digital 5.1--usually the Japanese soundtrack is only two-channel.
There are a few additions to the episodes, but usually very small adds. However, the four director's cut episodes have significant additions that explain things that would otherwise be confusing, which is good, because episode 21 is where the series really takes the story in a new direction.

Opinion:
Again, I watch the Japanese w/ subtitles. I was switching audio sources to compare English & Japanese and they sounded exactly the same except for the vocals. It also reminded me why I watch the Japanese versions--in one scene, Toji gave Ryoko a small item. The English actor said "I guess the cat's out of the bag" but the subtitles showed "Here is a cat souvenir for you" (not exact quotes). The English one makes it sound like he's giving her a secret clue to the rest of the story instead of just giving her a cat coin (she collects cat stuff). Plus, you get to see how many ways the sound for "yes" is used ("yes sir, yes, yeah, probably" are all the same word, just different levels of inflection).

Should you buy it?
Here's how you should do it:
1) Rent "End of Evangelion". You will either love it or hate it, but it provides an alternate ending to the series. Personally, I love it, but I also appreciate the original ending. If this movie makes you want to find out what's going on, then you will enjoy the series. If you thought the movie was stupid and you didn't care about the characters then you will not like the series, so you just saved yourself the cost of the .
2) Buy this collection. You WILL watch it again, so you will enjoy the excellent transfer quality for a bargain price.

Note: I revised this review to strip out renting Perfect collection first. There really is no reason to do this since Wikipedia has more info than the extras. Check out these sites for detailed NGE info:
[...]

5/5 Evangelion Perfection
  by Antonio D. Paolucci (Beaver Falls, PA)
The changes in the Platinum version of Evangelion from the Perfect Collection are small, with four director's cut episodes and commentary. (I received an e-mail recently, which noted I left out 5.1 sound and better picture quality, though than anime still looks washed and the sound is only clear in surround sound). But, they are changes in what is perhaps one of the best animes ever created, and to fans, that is more than enough to spend their money.

If that wasn't enough for you then, then here is your opportunity. Take it from someone who thrives off of these thin-pack box sets. The value of them is beyond compare. All of them have sturdy boxes with artwork on them. You get entire series for what is usually half the price you would spend buying the entire series, and you save on shelf-space. In this case, where there were seven DVDs in the entire series that go for $27 a pop (7 x 27 = 189 plus tax and possibly shipping), you'll end up saving big. How can you beat that?

I recommend this for anyone who doesn't have the original box set and for fans of anime of the highest quality. This is the best giant-robot anime, one of the top ten ever, and will go down as something magical and important in anime in the same way that Akira did. Plus, I recommend this for the value itself (7 x 27 = 189 - 48 = 141 = How can you beat that?).

(ADDED LATER) I've received a lot of e-mail regarding the extra features, inserts, and DVD count, so I'm going to address these issues now. Firstly, there is only six DVDs, but the episodes are condensed into the six so there is no need to worry about that. The final disc contains the director's cut episodes. Also, there are few extras on the disc, and in case you enjoy the inserts that tend to come with DVDs, the DVDs in the box set won't have them.

5/5 A Masterful Work of Artistic Storytelling
  by Suzanne (Oklahoma City, OK United States)
*OVERVIEW and EPISODE REVIEWS:

Neon Genesis Evangelion (NGE) starts out simple enough. A story about a boy named Shinji Ikari coming to a futuristic city and using giant robot-like Evas (Unit-01 himself) to fend off the invading enemies called Angels. Along the way he meets a mysterious girl and pilot of Unit-00, Rei Ayanami, the fiery pilot of Unit-02 Asuka Langley Soryu, Director of Nerv Operations Misato Katsuragi, the brilliant scientist, Ritsuko Akagi and his estranged father and Nerv's Commander, Gendo Ikari. There's also an intriguing cast of minor characters including friends from his school, Toji and Kensuke and Nerv's Vice Commander Fuyutsuki. But it ends in a completely different place than where it began, with so much filling its creamy center that it's hard to know what to cover in a review.

Yes, it indeed starts out simple enough: Through the first 8 episodes you probably couldn't distinguish NGE from any other giant robot anime ever made. These episodes, while entertaining, are as straight forward as anime gets. Then, slowly but surely from episodes 9-13, the characters are given to more detailing. We get to know them better as more of their stories and histories are revealed. A beautiful example of this is in episode 9 when Asuka falls down, asleep, next to Shinji, who is then tempted to kiss her before something makes him stop. The story is expanded upon as more secrets are revealed, which leads to more questions.

But then, during episode 14, which starts out as a boring "recap", half way through we get the first glimpse of what this series is really about. After the title card we hear the voice of Rei, giving a surreal and beautiful monologue with similar images following on the screen. This bit is practically visual/audio poetry working together, and gives the first hints of what's to come. The psychological and philosophical leanings of this episode would start to become more prominent throughout the series.

Episode 15 is really where the gears shift. The story has slowly built our interest in the characters and the many secrets up to this point, with as much humor and light heartedness as seriousness. In 15 though things takes a more mature, complex, and somber turn - with the end being the catalyst for the brilliant episodes to come. Indeed, episodes 16 and 18 are two of the most dramatic works of fiction I've ever experienced, with 17 being the calm interlude between them.

But then 19 comes along and trumps them all. If I could describe the chills I had when watching that episode for the first time... simply put, I don't think dramatic storytelling gets any better. Episode 20 is one of the deepest and complex, further diving into the psychology and symbolism behind the show. 21's back stories are woven so intricately you forget that you're watching an anime as the breadth given to the characters are incredible. 21's finale also serves as one of the most emotional in the series.

22 is one of the most disturbing episodes, diving into the psychology of Asuka this time in a way that will leave you feeling a bit shocked. 23 does what 22 did for Asuka and applies it to Rei. It also has the biggest, most stunning revelation in the series at the end of the episode, as one of Nerv's big secrets is revealed. These episodes also bring much of the "bigger" picture between Nerv, Seele, and the secrets behind the Angels and 2nd Impact into focus, which leads to the climax. That climax hits with episode 24, with the introduction of the last angel Kaworu. While one of the most perplexing episodes (due to its cryptic plot and dialogue), its magnificent finale - played out appropriately to Beethoven's final movement of his monumental 9th Symphony - serves as an outstanding closure to the main series before the final two episodes.

The final two episodes completely forego the story that's been building up, and focuses instead on the psychology and philosophy behind the show and its characters. These two episodes are brilliant in their own right. Episode 26 in particular, with its deconstructing of the meanings of reality and freedom, and examining of so many psychological hot points in the show (one's self worth, for instance) is an artistic high point in anime. They are not completely un-story related though, as the "melding of minds" in these episodes are a major plot element. But this works out great for the director Hideaki Anno who probably loved being able to get many of these feelings out through this series and these two episodes in particular.

For those wanting a closure to the story of NGE, "The End of Evangelion" is the grand finale to end all grand finales. While it won't answer everything in a nice, neat way (this is not a show that hands you answers on a silver platter), it provides an astonishingly powerful and poignant conclusion to the story and to the NGE series. I can understand the frustration of fans after watching the series and then the final two "series" episodes, thinking this was the end. In reality, the movie was MEANT to be the conclusion, but because of budget and time problems it couldn't be completed in time. The "series" finale will still stand on their own as the alternate take, but they're an essential alternate take as this is an anime whose meanings stretch far beyond the mecha-sci-fi, boy-saves-world genre. But the film sets a new standard in the art of closing a series on the perfect note.

*SERIES REVIEW

While the layers of psychology, philosophy, and symbolism would crush most shows under their own weight and seeming pretentiousness, Anno handles them with adeptness and acute direction. He skillfully weaves them into the story to the point where everything makes complete sense in relation to the characters and storyline. In fact, if you really take time to analyze the story, the characters, and the relationship between the dialogue and visuals with the psychological, philosophical, and symbolic meanings, you'll see this series does indeed have more depth than almost all others that have attempted to tackle similar subjects. In fact, this is a series which almost has to be viewed several times, as there are recurring motifs (both visually and in the dialogue) which link important thematic elements strung throughout. And if you're not watching carefully, you'll miss them the first and maybe even second time around.

I think the reason these ideas become so important is very simple, and that's because of the characters. Anno doesn't just create a random bunch of soulless, mindless, anime characters. He creates characters that everyone can relate to on some level. Because these characters have such range and depth, we begin to really care about them and their struggles. In the end their struggles become our own and they literally become mirrors of our own psychological profiles and problems. We begin to grieve as we watch them deal with such (self) destructive behavior caused by their circumstances and consequential frames of mind. It's because of this that the viewer actually cares about the more portentous moments, no matter how grandiose they become. I think it's very important for those out there to understand that all the elaborate complexities of NGE wouldn't matter without the characters that carry the weight and meaning of it all.

NGE is a show of extremes. Ranging from scenes of palpable, viseral power that inspire shock and awe, to the most quietly surene, surreal, and beautifully touching moments. These scenes are woven together as fine and eloquently as the Beethoven Symphony they play in episode 24 itself. And like that symphony, even though the parts are outstanding, the whole is much greater than the sum.

I believe this is a work of resounding artistic depth. I'd go as far as to say it's one of the absolute greatest pieces of fiction ever made in any medium. This may sound like hyperbole, but there have been few - if any - fictional works that have effected me both emotionally and psychologically like NGE has. If you put in the time and effort to actively watch this series, it will reward as many repeat viewings as you care to give it, as new layers and meanings will be uncovered each time. And I think that is, if nothing else, the first sign of a work of artistic genius.

*DVD REVIEW:

The Platinum Edition is far and away better than the Perfect Collection. The remastered visuals and audio are extraordinary. It doesn't get better than watching the big explosions in 5.1 Surround Sound! The remastered visuals are equally as striking. The reduced frame shake and jitter is a phenomenal improvement from the previous edition. It seems like they almost went back and re-animated parts of the show, making almost every scene look more vivid, life-like and alive. The Subtitled translations is another thing worth noting, as these translations are, by and large, more accurate. Even though I now hate the English translation of the song doesn't match the melody (always found it funny why it did on the Perfect Collection), this is a more accurate translation. The packaging is the only disappointment. The box is nothing special, the DVD cases themselves contain no booklets or notes, and there's no extras on the DVDs. But you get what you pay for as the price is a bargain. If you want all the other stuff you have to buy the Platinum Collection 1+Box and the rest of the collection separately.

5/5 "God's in his Heaven, all's right with the world...."
  by trashcanman (Hanford, CA United States)
Watch Video Here: http://www.amazon.com/review/R5K62BN3S7ZRZ "If there is any meaning
In the fate that pulled us together,
Then I am, yes, the Bible
That teaches you of freedom."

I forgot to mention that the opening song, "A Cruel Angel's Thesis", is the most memorable and brilliant television theme ever to me, as is the opening animation that accompanies it. Like I said, first rate all the way. That particular verse isn't in the section of the song used to open the show, but I feel it may be the most revealing line of the song.

"Neon Genesis Evangelion" -or EVA for short- has it's detractors, but I'm afraid I'll never be able to see what they fail to see about this show. But to each their own, you know?
I just can't get enough of adult science fiction -and animated, no less- that has the cojones to make every character in it a f#&%ed up psychological mess. That is what's called the real world, baby, and we all live in it whether or not our choices in entertainment acknowledge that fact. Then there's the second-to-none attention to detail and the endless moral dilemmas that are the hallmark of any truly great adult anime show. The character's motivations are exceptionally well thought out and their interactions with each other form the true base of a show most would dismiss at a glance as a simple action cartoon. This is not a robot cartoon; this an exploration of the human mind at it's most basic and disturbing levels. This is my kind of series.

The final episode -brilliant and deeply unique as it is- takes place entirely inside one character's head and left many (me included) rather cold as far as wrapping things up. So hardcore EVA fans literally threatened the creator with death until he made a proper conclusion, Neon Genesis Evangelion - The End of Evangelion, which is mind-bendingly awesome and unfortuanately not included in tis set. I'm not condoning death threats or anything, but I am very glad that film got made and it stands as a testament to how much people love this show. "Neon Genesis Evangelion" is being remade in Japan as we speak as a series of films and a live-action adaptation is on the way as well. So while we EVA fans have much to look forward to, it never hurts to brush up on our history either. If you don't own this, buy it.

[ Correction: In the video, I mistakenly identified the "Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Perfect Collection" as the "Platinum Complete Collection", which is the very item I reviewed. Doh! ]


3/5 Good if you want the episodes but...
  by Kurt Stubenvoll
This is not the Platinum edition that you think it is. While it does contain the redone episodes and 4 director's cut episodes, it is very dissapointing otherwise. The real Platinum edition comes with a booklet for each dvd that explain things in the episodes (which is really cool if you want to know what its all about). In adition, as far as I can tell, all the extra's on the real DVDs are missing here. No commentary, no interviews, no nothing. Just the redone episodes plus the 4 directors cut episodes. Its great if you just wanted better looking and sounding episodes. Its a terrible let down if you thought you were getting all the cool extras for a great price.