3/5 To date, probably the most beautiful looking AND most vapid Korean science fiction film
  by Brian T (Canada)
NATURAL CITY (2003) Directed by Min Byong-chan. Arresting production design and state-of-the-art visual effects can't disguise a dull plot that borrows so liberally from BLADE RUNNER and GHOST IN THE SHELL that the word 'tribute' could warrant legal action. To date, this is probably the most beautiful looking AND most vapid Korean science fiction film to come down the pipeline, and one feels almost guilty in knocking it in the face of the undeniable amount of craftsmanship that went into it.

Set in a futuristic megacity in the year 2080, it's about a sullen policeman (Yu Ji-tae) who wants to extend the life of his beautiful android dancer Ria (Seo Rin) by finding a new host for her brain-chip. As she's nearing her sell-by date, which requires her complete destruction, this puts him at odds with fellow cop Noma (Yun Chan) and evil android Roy Batty...err...evil uber-android Jeon Doo-hong, who has plans on accessing android headquarters and programming a massive robot uprising. Flying police cars, slow-floating dirigibles with gigantic projection screens, endlessly vertical skyscrapers forming a mountain of technology in a post-war wasteland.

We've seen all this before. And indeed, it all looks amazing here. But what's missing is any depth of character to make the story more convincing. The leading man is a complete cipher whose motivations for prolonging the life of his robot are never explained or explored, and while his robot clearly has functional difficulties with her impending doom, Seo underplays these scenes to a fault, generating neither tension nor sympathy, only indifference about her fate. To give credit where it's due, Korean is one of the few Asian countries - and one of the few countries outside of America and Japan - even attempting high-minded science-fiction films such as this, WONDERFUL DAYS, 2009 LOST MEMORIES, and YESTERDAY. One hopes that one day, the quality of screen writing will improve to meet the superb level of technical artistry already apparent on screen.

The Korean 2-disc special edition had a remarkable array of extras that may not all be included on the U.S. edition, but hopefully they'll at least include the cool easter egg that could be found on disc 2 by arrowing up on the main menu to highlight '*REC'. This gave you access to what appeared to be a 7-minute, effects laden music video about the plight of a country devastated by a nuclear attack, which almost feels like the backstory to the main feature.

5/5 No, it is not just a "Korean Bladerunner"
  by Miguel B. Llora (Bay Point, California USA)
I have to admit something... I really liked it. It gave that soft sense that Logan's Run did when I first caught it on the big screen. OK, I should be getting a more Casshern, Bladerunner, sort of feeling - there is that too. Research tells me that Natural City was a a box-office sensation - but only in Korea. Not sure why... neither did Casshern - but that is more a reflection of us in the US than the filmmaking in Japan and in Korea. The movie plays at or around AD 2080 where genetic and mechanical engineering has reached an apex - man is playing god in a very systematic way. In this space and time it is simple to alter human DNA, manufacture clones and fuse humans with "neuro-chips." An explanation is in order...a neuro-chipped human clone known as a `Combiner' has become basic part of everyday life. There are effectively two stories: a romance and one more akin to the Matrix and all its epistemological musings - yes, it is actually deep. Nonetheless, it does tend to fall into the tried and tested Tae Guk Gi drawn out battle scenes and the usual Korean flair for the over dramatic. Byung-chun Min he does a pretty good job - not up to Oldboy but it is good fun. Natural City comes at the whole mecha combined with human phenom from a different angle. Natural City Science gives personalities and a soul to machines. Moreover, it turns the table on conventionality - the story behind Natural City is more weighty a prophecy - as soon as humans opt to become more like equipment and even choose to "love" machines it can become somewhat disconcerting. It is no Matrix but it is 2 hours well spent.

Miguel Llora

3/5 beautiful but emotionally chilling
  by Joseph Geni (Evanston, Illinois United States)
OK, so I haven't seen Blade Runner, which this film has been repeatedly compared to. I have, however, seen Ghost in the Shell. Switch around a few plot specifics regarding cyborgs and the various bodies in which they might unexpectedly be found, and this is pretty much a live-action remake. Add in a bit of Minority Report sci-fi-noir and a flair for horror-suspense, a 5th-Elementesque mystical pleasure cruise ship that can take you away to a fabled land of forgetfulness, and finally toss in some Matrix-esque high-speed martial arts and sweeping, post-apocalyptic panoramics, and you've got yourself a movie. (I've only scratched the surface with the homages here: there's a fair number of nods to A.I., and one section of the soundtrack is jacked almost verbatim from a bit in the Truman Show. But never mind all that.)

The reason I liken this to Ghost in the Shell above the others is because they both have the following:
a) Beautiful, absolutely, astoundingly, beautiful visuals
b) A female cyborg character who wonders about the nature of life. (Fortunately, on this note I am pleased to report that Natural City's dialogue is a bit less rigid and more, well, human, than Ghost in the Shell's was.)
c) Nefarious, antagonistic, body-hopping cyborg villains.

Maybe it's because it's live action and not animated, but in general I found the characters to be surprisingly compelling for a cyborg flick. But their development is jarring and their motivations or thoughts are often maddeningly unclear. There's Cyon, the prostitute, who spends the first half of the movie sneering at everyone and the second staring in dull detachment at the ongoing events as they spiral out of control around her. What's going on in her head as she becomes a target for both hero and villain alike? She's the most human character in the story, so I'd like to know. There's Ria, the cyborg that R., our protagonist, has fallen for. A major problem with the movie is that we encounter her just 3 days before she "expires." She appears to not be functioning so well. Was she always this stupurous and obedient? What exactly is the humanness within her that makes R. fall in love with her? I don't often say this, but some well-placed flashbacks might have been helpful. This is the lynchpin of the story. Since R. loves her so much, WE should love her too, at least a little. I feel sympathetic for the character, but more in the way that I felt sympathetic for a pet dog that is about to be put down, not in the way I would for the love of my life.
Which brings me to R., the main character, whose love takes him on a completely destructive path that everyone can see but him. At the start, we sympathize with him, because blind love and devotion is an emotion that is easy to sympathize with. But he is so clearly out of control, it is difficult to fathom or relate to the increasingly desperate steps he takes to try to save Ria's life.

Which in turn brings me to my major issue with this film. Put simply, I don't like the resolution of the plot. I won't say whether it ends happily or not, because that would be bogus, but what I will say is that happy or sad, I like my plots to resolve in an emotionally satisfying manner. So if a film is trying to make a statement about life and what it means to be alive and human (as I believe, to its credit, this one is), I would like it to do so in a coherent (and preferably life-affirming) manner. At the end of this, beautiful though it is, I had to wonder, what's it all mean?

5/5 Excellent Sci-Fi from South Korea
  by Terry Smith (Little Rock, AR USA)
Natural City is a visually stunning sci-fi movie produced in South Korea. It is dark, gritty, slow-moving film noir at its best. The plot revolves around a futuristic SWAT team hunting down rogue cyborgs and the love affair between one of the men and his cyborg girlfriend who is about to "expire". There are plenty of comparisons both in plot and in elements within the movie to Blade Runner, and in fact the director's cut of this film on Amazon is subtitled "Korean Blade Runner".

However, all of that said, Natural City is not a rip-off and is an awesome movie in its own right. It has an excellent story line, great acting, incredible visuals, action-packed scenes clearly inspired by The Matrix, and a very worthy Dolby Digital 5.1 surround soundtrack. The film has English subtitles; but otherwise, you would not be able to tell it apart from a Hollywood film. On the contrary, Hollywood hasn't produced science fiction on this level for quite some time.

In particular, many months were spent building small-scale models filmed for a lot of the special effects. I still find this technique of using miniatures "realistically superior" to 95% of the computer graphics produced these days.

If you love dark, post-apocalyptic, film noir science fiction then you will love this movie. It's worthy-enough to reside in your DVD collection next to Blade Runner and the Alien trilogy.

4/5 Beautiful movie, but very bloody
  by Pavel Peev (Bulgaria)
The story is similar to the "Bladerunner" movie: policemen fight bad cyborgs.
But all the actors are asians here.
There are futuristic buildings and beautifully designed surroundings.
There are very beautiful women, some of which are real, some of which are cyborgs.
Even occasional nudity is presented.
But there is an awful lot of shooting. The policemen are dressed like
anti-terrorists, with helmets and huge guns (resembling a car's muffler).
The movie is excellent, with romantic music and pretty sea and sunset landscapes.
So, I recommend it, as long as you don't mind the bloody shooting and fights.
I don't give it full 5 stars because of the bloodshed.

P.S. Today I learned that a Korean student has shot other students in Virginia Tech University.
Perhaps he was insipred by watching too many korean movies with shootings in them?