3/5 With a Little Luck....
  by Mark Baker (Santa Clarita, CA United States)
Ashley Albright (Lindsay Lohan) has lived a charmed life. When she goes outside in the rain, the sun comes out. She just misses a crowded elevator and winds up alone with a very cute guy. And when she must substitute for her boss at a meeting, she gets a promotion out of the deal.

Jake Hardin (Chris Pine), on the other hand, could use a few good luck charms. He works at the Rock 'n Bowl, a bowling alley with live musical entertainment. He's found a great new group in McFly (playing themselves), but can't get their CD to an executive no matter what he tries.

Ashley has put together a masquerade ball as a promotion for record label Masquerade. Jake tries to crash the party to get McFly's CD to the label's executive just one more time. The two meet, and its love at first site. When they kiss, however, everything changes.

It starts with Ashley breaking the heel of her shoe. Things go downhill from there, and she's soon unemployed and living with her two friends. Jake, meanwhile, gets McFly signed to a record deal and finds himself living in a great, spacious apartment with a limo at his service.

Ashley hates her new life, and tries everything she can think of to get her luck back. Her path keeps crossing Jake's and the two begin to fall in love. What will happen when Ashley learns the truth?

Yeah, I'll admit it. I'm a Lindsay Lohan fan. That coupled with some very funny previews made me want to see this movie. Unfortunately, it didn't live up to its potential.

Obviously with a movie like this, the story is fairly predictable. It falls on the humor and the actors to make the journey to the end well worth watching. The actors do a great job with their material. You can't help but root for Ashley and Jake to find some way to deal with whatever it is they are currently facing. And, of course, you're rooting for them to get together.

Unfortunately, the humor fell flat. While I don't mind slapstick, I don't enjoy humor where the person is in pain or is constantly making a fool out of themselves. The humor in this movie fell almost entirely into those categories. Instead of laughing, I spend most of the movie cringing, waiting for the joke to come.

The ending works well, however. It was very sweet and redeems much of the earlier parts of the film.

The musical group featured in the film, McFly, is a real band. They've just released a CD entitled (surprise, surprise) Just My Luck. I was impressed enough with them to consider buying it but haven't yet.

The movie's ok, and the friend I went to see it with loved it. I just couldn't stop cringing enough to fully enjoy it. Three and a half stars rounded down.

3/5 Standard rental fare: light, predictable, and mostly pleasant..
  by A. G. Corwin
Hollywood loves to make these kinds of movies. A thrown together script, a marketable star, and enough eye candy to keep you interested enough to check the movie out. Movies like this are a dime a dozen, and make enough money that they continue to get made. Just My Luck shows enough warmth and charm to make it worth the $4 at the video store.

Tabloid queen and controversial star Lindsay Lohan plays Ashley, a girl whose simply can't do anything wrong, as she is blessed with excessive good luck. So she has a ridiculously large apartment(even though her job is low level PR). the ability to cab through Manhattan without hitting a red light, a flirtatious manner that draws the most handsome rich young men to her (in elevators no less), and of course some wonderful friends. The only really redeeming thing about Ashley is her friends. There is nothing particularly lovable about her. Jake on the other hand, is the sad sack whose luck is so bad he seems to balance out Ashley's. Working in a bowling alley, repping a band without success, Jake makes the audience feel for him, especially since he has a touching relationship with his niece.

Cue the masquerade ball, which Ashley throws to celebrate her new client, a P-Diddy like record mogul. Jake sneaks in to give the guy his band's CD, meets Ashley, they kiss, and suddenly their luck reverses. And this is where the movie redeems itself. Lohan begins to warm up as Ashley hits the bottom, becoming a more likable and natural character. Despite his incredible luck, Jake is still good hearted, even as he is making his clients, McFly, into the next big thing. Meeting Ashley, he helps her back on her feet before she realizes he was the one who got her luck, and gets it back. But of course, being Hollywood, her friends convince her to give the luck back to Jake in time for McFly to rock the house at their big concert debut. Cue happy ending.

Though the ending seems rushed so all the loose ends get neatly tied up, the film manages to find the warmth and heart that it lacked early on. And despite Lohan's problems off the screen (Lindsay, please please eat something), this film shows enough of the accessible and warm Lindsay from Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen and Mean Girls to make it worth seeing. Overall though, this is a decent film that makes for a good rental. Only buy if you really loved this film or are that big a fan of Lindsay.

A.G. Corwin
St.Louis, MO

3/5 It was a'right......
  by SereneNight (California, USA)
Ashley (Lindsay Lohan) stars as a yuppie who takes life (and her luck) for granted. After meeting loveable loser Jake (Chris Pine), he siphons away her luck with a kiss turning her luck sour. Can Ashley restore her luck to its former greatness or is she destined to be a loser?

This was an enjoyable lightweight comedy with unchallenging dialog, pretty people and a few really funny scenes. I enjoyed it, but I got a bit bored during the part where Ashley's luck runs bad. I don't really like watching someone constantly humiliated and embarrassed, even fictionally, and I'm not a huge fan of slapstick so the scenes with the washer and dryer and the blow dryer were 'meh' moments for me. Overall, it was a cute film but nothing ground breaking. 3 stars.

4/5 A good first attempt
  by Don't tread on me (North Carolina, USA)
As Lindsay Lohan transitions from Disney children movies (which I adored her in The Parent Trap), this movie is best called a good first attempt. It drags a bit and is quite predictable in its story line. Those are the only reasons that I did not give it 5 stars.
I hope that this is an indication of what Lindsay will be pursuing in her career. The humor is not crude or tasteless. The supporting cast is fairly good in this. I wish the fortune teller would have been more incorporated in the story. She was interesting and funny.
I am not sure why this movie got the PG-13 that it did. I have see plenty of PG-13 movies that should have been R or worse.

A good enjoyable movie worth renting and possibly adding to your collection.

4/5 Lindsay Lohan strikes all the right notes in her first romantic comedy
  by eric_f (Boston, MA)
Contrary to what many people think, I find Lindsay Lohan to be an above-average talent in the entertainment industry, and more intelligent than people give her credit for. Admittedly though, I prefer her acting to her singing. I've enjoyed her work in films such as "Freaky Friday," "Mean Girls" and "Herbie: Fully Loaded," all aimed at a younger demographic. With "Just My Luck," Lohan graduates into the young adult romantic comedy genre, complete with a business suit and all (which, I'll add, she looks MIGHTY GOOD in).

So does she pull it off? I would say without hesitation that she most certainly does. While this type of role isn't necessarily difficult to play, Lohan adds all the required charm and likeability to her character. There are some genuinely funny moments in the movie, thanks to a great supporting cast. And Chris Pine is also good as the lucky guy who wins Lohan's heart.

Romantic comedies are like action movies...we all know how they're going to end. But what matters is what happens in between point A and point B. And "Just My Luck" has all the right ingredients for a successful film, with a positive message thrown in for good measure. Recommended.