3.5/4  Scorsese at it again!! Best Director Ever??
If there was ever a doubt of Scorsese's talent and storytelling ability this film puts those doubts to rest. It is obvious from the first scene and the first line all the way through to the ending credits that Scorsese put every fiber of h... (read full)

4/4  Intense
I would have to say this is one of Scorsese's better films. Daniel Day-Lewis and Leonardo DiCaprio display some pretty well acted scenes and dialogue throughout this entire move. One of the more surprising aspects of this movie is Cameron ... (read full)

2/4  All over the place.
Incredibly well shot, and somewhat well acted, Dicaprio and Diaz are not perfect in this. The problem though is the music is very odd in some places like the opening battle sequence and the movie is all over the place and cannot decide wha... (read full)

2.5/4  Not bad but unfortunately not great.
I was very pumped up to see Gangs of New York. It seemed to be that Scorsese was making an epic about the city he had grown up in and set most of his movies in, and I didn't think there was any way he could fail. Unfortunately I was only p... (read full)

2/4  Disappointed.
One of the most boring movies I've ever seen, for simply fact that is a Scorsese. I'm not a big fan of him, but he has his masterpieces (Taxi driver). This one is a flaw. Fake characters and boring story that seems to never get a point. It... (read full)

3/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
Great performances, a riveting story and visually amazing - Martin Scorsese does it again - and he does it well. I won't say it's my favorite out of all his films, but it certainly helps solidify him as one of the great modern directors.

3.5/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
Electrifying performances with outstanding direction and brilliant writing!

3/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
I liked this movie. It's a Daniel Day-Lewis movie, so you know it's going to be good.

2.5/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
Meh. I expected better.

4/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
Best Ending scene in movie history and great scorsesse epic. i like everything about this movie. reminds me john ford classics maybe thats why.

4/4  Gangs of New York Quick Review
This movie made me a strong believer in Leonardo DiCaprio...but Lewis steals the show as a perfect "Bill the Butcher." As always with Scorsese, it has perfect music, great cinematography, and wonderful revenge story. It is just short of greatness...

3/5 Pangs of New York
  by Randy Keehn (Williston, ND United States)
"Gangs of New York" is one of those periodic films that grabs a lot of Oscar nominations and comes away with no statuettes. "Peyton Place" was the reigning champ in this dubious category but Scorcese's film gave them a run for the money. After watching it the other night, I came to understand why this happened; The movie opens strong and closes nearly as strong while the interminable bulk of the movie meanders in a repetitious drone. If Scorcese had a point, he should have made it. I took time out for supper without a second thought. Leftovers were better than what needn't have been served in the first place.

When I say that the film opened strong I guess I'd better qualify my statement. The build-up to a gang war with no quarter was a bit overdone but at least it gave the viewer a sense that this was going to be one of those action movies that can succeed without the extranvagance of a plot. That's the problem; without the action we are left with a rather ridiculous cast of characters. I understand that this is based on real Gotham history and I was focussed on the subtleties leading up the the New York Draft Riots. However, that singularly important event was forced to play a duet with a lesser talent. The resulting Armaggedon left me wondering if there was anything left in New York City that was worth salvaging. I read complaints about the lack of a "Director's Cut" that would have added an hour or so to this lengthy Leviathan. This was not a case of too much left out but, rather, too much shoved in.

4/5 Gangs of New York
  by J. Lindner (Gem Lake, MN United States)
This film shows the brutality of New York's Five Points district set in part against the draft riots of 1863. The characters evolve around the political scene established by Boss Tweed and Tammany Hall each recognizing the internal hierarchy of where the streets and politics come together. To make it appealing the director threw in graphic violence and dashes of nudity, but all in all this is a good, entertaining film.

Don't use this movie as a history lesson beyond the scope of the film, it is by no means a documentary. But take it for what it is and you will be entertained. The film also followed the attacks of 9-11 and shows the resiliancy of New York. The city was in flames after the military put down the draft riots, but it rose again. Martin Scorcese wanted to show New Yorkers that they would rise again following the attacks. He even added several still photos of the city at the very end of the film to make this point.

4/5 Pleasantly surprised
  by R. ADRAGNA (NY, United States)
Having owned the standard DVD and from some reviewers comments I wasn't expecting the Blu-Ray to be top notch, well I was pleasantly surprised. The film looked better than I expected, yes edge enhancement is overdone in some scenes, but overall it looked great.
The surround sound was excellent. As to the film, the first two thirds is great, the last seems overloaded and rushed, with too much historical detail, a lot of it could have been made into another film. I enjoyed the film more this time around.



4/5 Gangs of New York Two-Disc
  by britton522

Having seen the movie before, I bought this to update my library. My copy does not have the collectors' edition banner on it.

The extras on the movie are great, and I'm sad to see that Amazon seems to no longer post what they are! The special features usually determine which edition of a film I will buy, so this information is very much missed!
That said, here's how the back cover of mine reads:
*Costume Design featurette
*Set Design featurette
*History of the Five Points
*Exploring the Sets...With Multiple Angles Utilizing 360 Degree Shots of the Set
*U2 Music Video
*Discovery Channel Special: Uncovering the Real Gangs of New York
*The Five Points Study Guide
*Feature Commentary with Martin Scorsese
*Trailer
*Teaser
*French Language track

And, of course, it does offer English subtitles. The historical extras are excellent and informative, but the study guide was a little baffling: it's presented in text with no voiceover, and the font was so small I couldn't read it easily about six feet from my 32" tv. As far as documenting the film itself, the specials and trailers doa good job of preserving the movie's history.

The fly in the ointment:
Like the Titanic 3-disc, Gangs cuts halfway through for you to insert the second disc, during the sex scene. Why you wouldn't put the movie on one disc and the extras on another is beyond me, but to cut it there? There are many complaints concerning this also posted on imdb, and no one seems to know why this decision was made. We may have progressed to the age of dvd and blu-ray, but we're still stuck getting up to change the tape.

3/5 Great Movie, Bad Transfer
  by DryvBy (Knoxville, TN USA)
For those unfamiliar with the movie, it's a film about gangs in New York during the civil war fighting for control over the Five Points. This review is more of a review for the Blu-Ray, not the movie itself. I'd say based on the movie alone, it's a good 5 star for those interested in some dark history of New York.

For the transfer of this film, it's horrible. The noise is filtered in some scenes enough to make the film seen 'dirty' or blurred. The blacks seem to bleed a bit in dark scenes and for those with LCD screens, expect to notice some motion blur during these scenes. I never notice motion blur on my Samsung, but this movie (and Donnie Darko) are blur in any scene with shadows. I really think this is due to all of the horrible noise filters. At time's, the Butcher's hate (a green color) has movement issues towards the end. You can see details moving around that just doesn't look right. This really only applies to the video quality, as the uncompressed PCM audio is very nice (a little low in areas though).

Overall, anyone looking for this film should probably wait to see if it is going to be re-released. I think current owners should get a free upgrade to a better quality if that's ever released (which I doubt it will happen).