5/5 Ryan Reynolds break through
  by T. Johnson (Portland, OR)
This is the best Ryan Reynolds movie I've seen. It displays his full range of acting ability (which is quite good - he can be extremely funny but also has full dramatic leading man capacity) and the movie is just surprisingly good. I recommend this movie. As a strange aside that just popped into my head, Adam Sandler should step aside from doing movies like Click and Bedtime Stories and hand those roles over to Reynolds - he would have made those movies twice as good.

Anyway it was a good story with nice twists, much less predictable than many romcoms, it was funny and just plain good. Ryan Reynolds is something of a revelation in this role.



5/5 romantic movie
  by Lisa Thomas
I love the story line and the entire cast. I especially love Ryan Reynolds and Isla Fisher's characters.

5/5 definitely maybe
  by PIA (Rochester, NY)
Great movie...well done... put it right up there near Notting Hill and A Lot Like Love... music could've been a little better... bill

5/5 Dynamic Romantic Comedy
  by Y. Kostiv (Ukraine)
An obvious romantic comedy, but pretty dynamic as the scene is New York. Few good jokes, sweet main characters, especially the child.. Loved Summer's comments, love NY humor!

4/5 Definitely Maybe
  by Daisy Bug
This is a great little chick flick and has the added enjoyment of trying to guess the answer to the little girls query before they tell us.