5/5 Undiscovered Holiday Classic
  by Captain Bluebelle (Bayfield, CO United States)
Undiscovered by most, but luckily discovered by me this Christmas. I love old movies for their glimpse back in time, the clothes, the way they talked, the integrity that people tried to live by. While some old movies have bland plots that don't keep my interest, this did because of the depth of the screenwriting and insight into what's important in life. I'll watch this again year after year!

5/5 One of our Favorite Christmas Movies
  by njmceach (Kelowna B.C. Canada)
We had been waiting for several years for the DVD Holiday Affair to be released. We were so happy to get it.

3/5 I guess I'm in the minority here
  by Alena (New York, NY USA)
I guess I am in the minority here, but I couldn't get into this movie. I love Christmas movies and movies from this era but this movie didn't click with me. The acting isn't bad, but the suiters for our heroine's hand didn't seem convincing and the son, Timmy, just seemed squeaky and annoying.

If you want a great Christmas movie from the 40's, try Christmas in Connecticut! My whole family loves that movie!

5/5 A Fine Romance
  by David Baldwin (Philadelphia,PA USA)
Ostensibly this is marketed as a holiday film but it's appeal is for all seasons. How rare a romantic film involving a love triangle where all the principals are full-blooded characters. We naturally root for the Robert Mitchum and Janet Leigh characters to connect but we have more than a dollop of sympathy for Wendell Corey. Some comic elements but the film smacks of romantic drama. As a bonus Harry Morgan has a terrific bit as a harried police lieutenant. Highly recommended. Torn between giving the film four or five stars but in the spirit of the holidays I'll lean towards the latter.

5/5 Holiday Affair
  by K. Burke
I love this version. There is one before it, and one after it, but this is the best.