3/5 What, No Blu-ray version???
  by HK FROM THE BRONX
I think it's great that we live in an era where this collection is even available for true fans of the game especially the NY FOOTBALL GIANTS! However, since these games were originally broadcasted in HD it would've been nice to have this collection available on Blu-ray! The features, commentary etc. would've been a 1,000% improvement over the DVD version in my humble opinion.

5/5 Great DVD Set
  by T. Kotz (Asheville, NC United States)
Great DVD production ... took care of what I was going to do to copy my VHS tapes to DVD and edit out the commercials... well worth the price and .... great to relive these top 10 games. Go G-Men

4/5 Great video quality, somewhat poor packaging, no pre/postgame
  by PatrickG (Stamford, CT)
Let me start by saying that I've only watched the three games from 1986 so far, and I will come back to update the review as I get farther into the set.

To clear up one thing right off the bat, the case itself states it's 1000 minutes for all 10 games, so that's an average of under 2 hours per game. Cut out from the footage is the usual stuff... there is no pregame, halftime, or postgame. There are also some edited huddles, but the majority of time edited out are where the commercial breaks used to be as well as change of possessions. The edits are pretty seemless, and it appears that what they cut out wasn't all that significant because they also show plenty of footage in between plays (Madden and Summerall analysis, replays, etc).

The advantage to owning this set is that the video quality of these games from '86 are MUCH better than my VHS tapes or even DVDs that can be found in trading circles. So I'll watch these when I get a sudden craving for watching one particular game, and I'll use the original airing DVDs when I'm looking for the full experience (like if I'm watching the full season from start to finish, or when I want to see the games as well as other footage as a reminder to what everyone was saying about the teams as the playoffs progressed).

Now for the packaging... it's both good and bad. It's great that they've managed to get 10 discs into such a small box. The package is the same size as many double disc movies. On the bad side, and it's really bad, is that the hubs that hold the discs in place are so tough and inflexible that you have to bend the disc severely in order to get it out of the case. And since there are two discs on each "page", you end up bending two discs at the same time. I've certainly seen this before with movies I've purchased, and I just wish that the companies releasing these things would get a clue in that regard.

I'll be back as I watch more of the set...

5/5 1000 minutes of great memories
  by Peter D. Knapp (Bayport, New York United States)
It's great to finally have some Giants games
to add to my collection. My VHS tapes
haven't held up over the last 20+ years!

4/5 Couple of games I wish they'd included
  by James Dibenedetto (Arlington, VA USA)
This is a great set, but there are a few games I wish they'd included...

Giants vs. Dallas, week 16, 1981 - OT victory for the Giants to clinch their first playoff spot in 18 years

Giants vs. Washington, week 9, 1984 - crushing 37-13 win over the 'Skins, and also the game where the Gatorade Bath was born

Giants vs. 49ers, Wild Card playoff, 1985 - first Giants home playoff game since 1962, great 17-3 win

Giants vs. 49ers, week 11, 1986 - comeback from 17-0 down at halftime on Monday Night.

Giants vs. Vikings, week 12, 1986 - Bobby Johnson's catch on 4th and 17 to save the game

Giants vs. Broncos, week 13, 1986 - Super Bowl preview, great game that went down to the final play, George Martin's epic fumble return for a TD

Giants vs. 49ers, week 12, 1990 - yeah, it was a loss, but it was one of the most intense Monday Night games ever played.

Giants vs. Broncos, week 14, 1998 - Giants hand 13-0 Denver their first loss in a great, tight game

Giants vs. Redskins, week 16, 2006 - Tiki Barber rushes for over 200 yards to clinch a playoff spot.