5/5 Perfect gift for the Trekkie in your life!
  by Skip George (Atlanta, GA)
I bought this for my partner as a birthday present. He has thoroughly enjoyed this, and I recommend to anyone that has a Trekkie or sci-fi person in their life.

3/5 Generations disc defective
  by John P. Mason (Colonial Heights VA USA)
The picture and sound are great in this set except for the Generations movie. This disc was defective. The contrast and color are bad. I emailed Paramount, asking about an exchange a couple of weeks ago, but got no reply. I have no way of knowing whether all the Generations discs have this problem, but I was not pleased with mine (although the other movies are great) and I am even less pleased with the lack of response from Paramount.

3/5 Good deal if you don't already own them.
  by Brent Collins (North Dakota)
Theatrical version only. No director's cuts available in this box set. HD quality good, but nothing spectacular about the conversion. Lots of extras for each movie, including deleted scenes and an alternate ending for Insurrection. Worth buying if you don't already own these on DVD or are just collecting for the sake of completeness.

5/5 A must-have for TNG fans
  by Alex Alban (Springfield, MA USA)
A must-have for TNG fans. PQ of the movies is decent, and while the supplementals from the movies aren't in HD they are still wonderful if you haven't seen them. The fifth disc is a supplemental disc and it is in HD.

Generations:
PQ: 2
Movie: 2
Comments: I'm not a fan of Kirk, and while Data is my favorite character I hate when he uses the emotion chip, he acted like such a fool in this movie. This movie was quite boring.

First Contact:
PQ: 4
Movie: 5
Comments: The best movie in this set and in my opinion the best PQ. The close-up shot of Data in his interrogation by the Borg Queen was amazing.

Insurrection:
PQ: 3.5
Movie: 3
Comments: Decent PQ and decent movie, nothing special.

Nemesis:
PQ: 3
Movie: 4
Comments: I highly disagree with Martin Liebman's score for this movie's PQ, this movie is filled with a lot of grain, almost made me vomit. If this is what film is supposed to look like then I really hate film. The movie is decent.

5/5 quality improvement
  by Squid (Seattle, WA)
These are obviously the same Next Generation movies as before, but the quality difference between the regular DVD's and the bluray is substantial. The DVD's almost seemed grainy to me, and these have the very quality bluray definition.