2/5 Ugetsu it isn't
  by Open Mind (Bay Area)
All of the story lines are too predictable and overdone if not over"acted"...this is far off from the Japanese classic, Ugetsu. The beauty of the cinematography in this movie is symbolic and spirited, sometimes surreal, but cannot compare to that of the past masters.

1/5 JUST A FORSAKEN CRITERION EDITION... REFUSE TO TAKE.
  by HAN XIAO (CHINA)
Poor image quality was put onto a US theatrical cut of KOBAYASHI's masterpiece. What a shame! I'd rather believe Criterion didn't release this. In my opinion, MoC has released the best edition so far. Full-length director's cut, with brand new image restoration, although the trailer was lost, does it matter?

5/5 Kudos for Kwaidan
  by S. E. Rittenhouse
Haunting sets and sound effects for this series of Japanese tales of fantasy and horror. Memorable and worthy of the awards won.

2/5 Art-house Snobs Love This Stuff
  by Anticlimacus
Kwaidan is an anthology of four horror stories (The Black Hair, The Woman of the Snow, Hoichi the Earless, In a Cup of Tea) that have inexplicably garnered the praises of many fans of Japanese cinema, thus earning itself an 8/10 average rating on IMDb. Unfortunately, the film simply doesn't deserve the high rating, and it most definitely does not deserve 164 minutes of anyone's time.

As a horror feature, Kwaidan fails miserably. Quite literally, there is not one scene in any of the short films that is even marginally disturbing. In fact, the attempted horror was so badly executed that it came off as comedic. (1) The Black Hair spends 95% of its running time with the rather boring life of a man who leaves his wife for money and prestige, only to end with an incredibly stupid resolution - a wig that twitches on the ground, making the man grow old quickly. (2) The Woman of the Snow started off promising, but then ended horribly with the ghost deciding not to kill the man, even though the entire story was based on that commitment. (3) Hoichi the Earless had one scene that was a bit gruesome, but the title of the film gave it away about an hour or so before it happened, thus diminishing its impact to almost nothing. (4) In a Cup of Tea employed the worst horror elements I've seen in some time. A man sees a man's smiling face in his cup of tea. Oooh, I'm scared. If anyone is looking for a few chills, stay far, far away from this one.

The lack of horror is not compensated in the least with interesting dialogue or dramatic elements. The acting is not very good, and almost no interesting narrative occurs in the films 164 minutes. When one tries to find some kind of point or moral to these stories, one finds that there is very little actual content to warrant an objective conclusion. The filmmakers seemed intent on creating the most superficial, meaningless plot lines and characters possible. The motives for the supernatural entities are usually ambiguous. In addition, Kwaidan was just plain boring. And no, I don't mean slow-paced; I mean boring. Tokyo Story was slow-paced, but interesting. Cure was slow-paced, but interesting. I could list another 50 deliberately-paced films that move slower than molasses in January, but were still riveting. Kwaidan is just boring.

There's almost nothing in this film that's noteworthy, but the exception to this is its cinematography. The special effects were used well to create an otherworldly atmosphere, especially in The Woman of the Snow. Of course, this is just window-dressing to an otherwise shallow, below-average film that is in the end not very entertaining at all.

What annoys me the most is when defenders of this film claim that it is far superior to Asian horror films made during the past decade. Such a claim is totally misguided. Kwaidan has NONE of the masterful storytelling found in A Tale of Two Sisters (2003), NONE of the impending doom-like atmosphere of Kairo (2001), NONE of the creepiness or cleverness of Ju-on: The Grudge 2 (2003 theatrical), NONE of the interesting concepts found in Cure (1997), and NONE of the psychological contributions seen in Audition (1999), just to name a few. Basically, Kwaidan has NOTHING memorable whatsoever, while the Asian horror films of the past decade have just about EVERYTHING except the convenient luxury of being made before 1970 - a time that Kwaidan lovers consider their Garden of Eden, where every movie was a "work of art" or a "masterpiece." Give me a break.

I ponder at the reasoning behind the high rating here. Then I remembered: it's a boring Japanese film made in 1964. That's just about enough to impress any art house snob, or anyone who wants to feel "cultured" by liking a really bad horror film from the 60s.

5/5 Exquisite and haunting
  by Anthony Bezich
Kwaidan is an anthology of exquisite and haunting ghost stories. Each story takes the viewer into that state between waking life and dreams. There are boundaries but no walls to separate the two worlds. Leaving a treeline, crossing a stream, or stepping through a threshold, the phantoms readily follow the dreamer back into his wakeful and once ordinary life.

The Criterion edition of Kwaidan is excellent. The transfer is beautiful.