5/5 Great Flat Picking Book
  by S. Danner
I have really enjoyed this CD and book. I would highly recommend it for an intermedia player or an advanced beginning that is looking to challange themself

3/5 Don't buy it if you want complete tab
  by Disappointed (Texas)
If you are a fan of Mr. Kaufman and Mr. Watson it is worth buying. I will enjoy watching the playing. That being said, if you are expecting the songs listed to be completely tabbed, you won't get it. Some of the songs just have the breaks tabbed. I bought it as a beginner who wanted to learn "Little Sadie". Granted it's advertised Level 3 (intermediate), but it's also advertised to include music and Tab. Homespun does great videos. To be honest I expected a little more.

4/5 Worth the money, but be prepared to put effort into picking up licks and runs on your own
  by J. Amick
As mentioned in other reviews, the overall quality of this DVD is very good. I was hoping for more footage of just Doc's lead without any accompaniment so you can sort out exactly what is going on. The slow examples that are played are a little faster than I would prefer, but they are helpful none the less. The tab was a little disappointing, for the money I expected a full tab in a book. The partial tab booklet that comes with the DVD is helpful, but be prepared to do it the old fashion way... lifting licks by playing parts of the DVD over and over again. It is extremely helpful to see Doc's left hand so you can know what position he is picking out of when compared to figuring out runs from a CD. It's worth buying if you're serious about learning Doc Watson's style.

4/5 Great to watch Doc play, but he isn't teaching much
  by K. D. Wade (Anderson, IN United States)
Doc Watson is a great guitar player, and getting the closeup view of his hands as he plays is instructive and interesting. Great self-taught players who manage to be genuinely innovative, as Doc Watson is, always have some quirks in their technique, and Doc is no exception.

The problem is that Doc doesn't really know how to teach what he does. Like I said, he's self-taught; I don't think he has much frame of reference for how to explain what he does. He plays everything too fast and doesn't focus on dissecting his more intricate runs.

Still, though, you do get the feeling that you're almost sitting right in front of him and watching him play, and that in itself is instructive. You can learn from this DVD, but don't expect to come away from it a flatpicking master.

5/5 For beginner/intermediate players
  by J. Kussman
It's a good DVD, with a LOT of songs tabbed out. The songs played on this disc have a little bit of everything; runs, cross picking, and good-old fashioned flat picking. Worth the price if you want a breakdown of Doc's playing style and are looking to step up your game. I think this is appropriate for beginner to intermediate skill levels.