4/5 Imaginary Witness
  by Elizabeth A. Normandin (Boston)
I found it to be so enlightening.I've seen almost all the movies that were decribed in DVD

5/5 Brilliant and Compelling Documentary on American Filmmakers and the Holocaust
  by Steven I. Ramm (Phila, PA USA)
Remember when AMC (formerly American Movie Classics) used to actually show movies (and without commercials)? This DVD takes us back to 2004 when, like Turner Movie Classics, the cable channel showed quality films as well as specially produced documentaries. Thanks to Koch and their Koch Lorber Films division, the superb film has a new life. And it belongs in every 20th century history course - in high school as well as college - as well as every film-making course.

The 92-minute film - directed by Daniel Anker, and narrated by Gene Hackman - begins years before the Holocaust with Warner Brothers' films - many recently reissued as part of their "Gangster" series - on prejudice against the Jews in the US. And then we are up to Chaplin's "The Great Dictator" and Jack Benny as Hitler in "To Be Or Not To Be".

Then comes the Holocaust and the end of World War II. But it isn't until President Eisenhower sends 16 Hollywood moguls to Germany to see the horrors in the concentration camps, that films start to be made to educate Americans about the atrocities and tell the story.

With interviews with stars and Directors, Producers and scriptwriters and film historians (all listed in an earlier review on this site, so I won't list again), and SIGNIFICANT footage from the more recent films and TV mini-series (most notably the 30-hour-long "War and Remembrance" (1988), the story is graphically told. I did not remember how graphic some of the recreated scenes in the "W&R" series was, but it really grabs you and won't let go.

With the cooperation of the "A" list of Hollywood directing and producing community, the is certainly the best documentary on the subject I have seen and the video and film clips are in pristine condition.

There are no special features, but you'll be thinking about the scenes you've seen for hours after you've turned off your TV.

HIGHEST RECOMMENDATION!

Steve Ramm
"Anything Phonographic"












5/5 Traces the history of Holocaust portrayal in Hollywood movies
  by z hayes (plano,texas)
I found this documentary to be a compelling watch. It begins with an explanation for the lack of portrayal in Hollywood movies about the rising Nazi threat back in the early 1940s. The reason for this was due to the fact that Germany accounted for 10% of Hollywood's foreign market. But economics wasn't the only reason for the dearth of anti-Nazi depictions in movies made by Hollywood. There was quite a bit of anti-semitism within the US itself - e.g. the Ku Klux Klan and the German Bunde [sic], an organization that was based in the US and represented the interests of the sizable German population in the States did not want to see attacks on Hitler or the Nazis.

Yet, there were some compelling portrayal of life under the Nazis and how it affected the Jews. Movies like The Mortal Storm with Jimmy Stewart told the story of a respectable, upper middle class Jewish family in Germany and how the anti-semitic movement in Germany under Hitler and the Nazis affects them. There are also movies like The great Dictator starring Charlie Chaplin [who funded the movie himself], playing dual roles of a Jewish barber and a parody of Hitler. It was in the Great Dictator that the word "Jew" is first referenced in a Hollywoood production [even in the Mortal Storm, the phrase "non-Aryan" is used when referencing Jews].

This is a well-researched documentary and for someone like me who is keen on anything to do with the Holocaust and WW II history, I found it to be a minefield of interesting historical facts and trivia. I made a list of classic movies that I plan to look up and add to my library - movies like "To Be or Not to Be", starring Carole Lombard [a comedic attack on Nazi ideology], None Shall Escape [1944], The Search [1948], and Singing in the Dark [1956].

Besides covering the classic movies dealing with the Holocaust, there are also references to more contemporary productions such as Schindler's List, Sophie's Choice, War and Remembrance [1988 mini-series], and of course Holocaust [1978 mini-series].

A must-watch documentary for those interested in the Holocaust and Hollywood's depiction of it through the years.

4/5 "Imaginary Witness ... Hollywood & the Holocaust ... KOCH Lorber Films (2008)"
  by J. Lovins (Missouri-USA)
Koch Lorber Films presents "IMAGINARY WITNESS: HOLLYWOOD AND THE HOLOCAUST" (25 December 2007) (92 mins/B&W/Color) (Dolby Digital) --- This is an expertly made documentary on Hollywood, not just how they handled one topic, but how they are embroiled in current politics --- There will be some surprises to some moviegoers and clips from some relatively unknown gems, some of which I have never seen and will now seek out! --- Otherwise, I have to give this documentary a big thumbs up --- Narrated by Gene Hackman and featuring a remarkable series of clips and interviews, IMAGINARY WITNESS is a revelation, not least for its large inclusion of material from BEFORE the Holocaust even happened, including American newsreel footage of Nazi book burning that treat it like a fraternity prank and pre-war Hollywood films in which characters refer to Jews as non Aryans --- This is one documentary not to be missed.

Under the production staff of:
Daniel Anker Director, Producer
Andrew Barrett Score Composer
Ellin Baumel Producer
Diana Holtzberg Executive Producer
Tom Hurwitz Cinematographer
Susan Kim Co-producer
Jan Rofekamp Executive Producer
Nancy Schreiber Cinematographer
Brad Shaw Editor

Story line and plot, This is what Hollywood needed to do -and what not- to expose Nazi Germany's intentions --- It is a well-documented film with great interviews and original footage to prove that cinema can be used to fight for the right and wrong of world events --- In my book this is a great film to illustrate how everyone turned their back on what Hitler was doing against the Judaism --- Nevermore, please --- Some of the raw footage is missing when American troops discovered the death camps --- However, the narration accomplished the feelings of those who were watching back then --- Produced for the cable television network American Movie Classics, Imaginary Witness: Hollywood and the Holocaust was premiered at the 2004 Tribeca Film Festival.

the cast includes:
Gene Hackman ... Narrator
Ben Kingsley
Liam Neeson
Norma Barzman ... Herself
Michael Berenbaum ... Himself
Robert Berger ... Himself
Tom Brokaw ... Himself (voice) (archive footage)
Robert Clary ... Himself
Dan Curtis ... Himself
Michael Dunn ... (archive footage)
Stanley Frazen ... Himself
Neal Gabler ... Himself
Annette Insdorf ... Herself )
Sidney Lumet ... Himself
Branko Lustig ... Himself
Abby Mann ... Himself
Gene Reynolds ... Himself
Sharon Rivo ... Herself
Irene Sachs
Vincent Sherman ... Himself
Steven Spielberg ... Himself
Martin Starger ... Himself
Rod Steiger ... Himself
George Stevens Jr. ... Himself
Malvin Wald ... Himself
Fritz Weaver ... Himself

Great job by Koch Lorber Films --- looking forward to more high quality titles from the International Collection Film Market --- order your copy now from Amazon or Koch Vision where there are plenty of copies available on DVD, stay tuned once again for top notch releases --- where they are experts in releasing long forgotten films and treasures to the collector.

Total Time: 92 mins on DVD ~ KOCH Lorber Films ~ (01/13/2009)