5/5 Great Old Movies
  by Jacquelyn K. Tank (Ohio)
If you love to curl up and watch old movies, tune in to this. I have always been a Doris Day fan. Combine her with Clark Gable (that's when men were men) and how much better could it get? This is when they made movies you knew you could sit down and watch with the family. I wish Hollywood would realize we're not all after R-rated material in our movies.

5/5 EXCELLENT
  by Phylesha L. Restrepo (WALL TWP' NEW JERSEY)
I ALWAYS LOVED THIS MOVIE ! SO IT ISN'T FAIR FOR ME TO SAY ANYTHING ABOUT IT. THE ACTING IS EXCELLENTLY WELL DONE. I'M A CLARK GABLE PERSON AND I ALWAYS LOVED DORIS DAY . IF YOU LOVE GREAT MOVIES WHEN MOVIES WERE STILL MADE WITH TASTE AND STYLE, AND WHEN MOVIES HAD A REAL THEME RUNNING THROUGH IT EVEN WHEN IT WAS COMICAL, YOU'LL LOVE THE TEACHER'S PET...

4/5 gable make facial expressions
  by M. L. Hunt (Okie)
If you love Gable movies, you will love this one. Gable's facial expressions in this movie are great, worth the price of the dvd..


4/5 Post-WWII Shift in Journalism Ethos Lends Heft to an Expertly Played May-December Rom-Com
  by Ed Uyeshima (San Francisco, CA USA)
Directed by George Seaton (Miracle on 34th Street), this coyly titled 1958 romantic comedy has more on its mind than mistaken identities and the May-December relationship at its core. Running a bit too long at 120 minutes, it's actually an intriguing look at the shifting journalism ethos of the late 1950's when hardcore, Front Page-style newspapermen were begrudgingly making way for reporters with college degrees. It should come as no surprise that Clark Gable represents the former as Jim Gannon, the no-nonsense editor of the fictitious New York Evening Chronicle, at odds with journalism teacher Erica Kane played with sophisticated élan by Doris Day, who was just embarking on her most fruitful period as an actress with her near-classic pairings with Rock Hudson soon to follow.

Written by Fay and Michael Kanin, the plot has the self-made Gannon bristling at the thought of lecturing at Kane's night school journalism class. When his boss forces him, Gannon reconsiders when he sees that Kane is a pretty blonde but is soon forced to take on the identity of wallpaper salesman Jim Gallagher when she humiliates him by reading out loud to her class the nasty letter he wrote her. The ruse continues as Gannon decides to prove that journalism classes are a sham and that nothing replaces the first-hand experience of working in a newsroom. Things get complicated when he becomes her star pupil and sees his competition for Kane's affections, the dapper Dr. Hugo Pine, a self-effacing overachiever who happens to be a much-published psychologist, an expert mambo dancer, a polyglot, and a smooth bongo player. You can pretty much figure out the rest.

As Gannon/Gallagher, the 57-year-old Gable was near the end of his career, and he looks tired and paunchy here. Fortunately, he provides enough of his recognizable swagger and snap to get away with the hard-boiled aspects of the role. At this point in her career, Day had already moved securely away from the lightweight musical comedies that were her forte and into leading lady parts with surprising aplomb. Underneath the manicured schoolteacher veneer, she brings a wholesome yet mature sexiness to Kane that makes the age gap between her and Gable less of an issue than one would expect. Playing his standard role of third wheel, Gig Young does an agile turn as the too-good-to-be-true Dr. Pine. Nick Adams (who would attempt to seduce Day the following year as a carefree college boy in Pillow Talk) has a small part as Barney, the copy boy desperate to become a reporter, while Marilyn Monroe-wannabe Mamie Van Doren has a memorable bit as Gannon's showgirl squeeze. That is indeed a young Marion Ross (later Mrs. Cunningham of Happy Days) as Kane's secretary Katy. There are no extras with the 2005 DVD.

5/5 Romantic Comedy
  by Handmaiden (Just Passing Through)
If you are a Doris Day or Clark Gable fan then you are in for a real treat. I thought this was a terrific movie that I remember watching years ago, and Amazon sells this at such a reasonable price.