4/5 Good history, entertaining, worth the buy
  by MUS
I bought this DVD as a fan of the 4 Horsemen who didn't start watching pro wrestling until around 1990, so I learned so much about the prime of the "original gang of professional wrestling" that I wish I had experienced then.

The DVD seems to provide a strong chronology of how the group formed and describing the elements that were added and that were missing with each change in the membership of the group and how that chemistry separated the 4 Horsemen from a created faction or manufactured story. It made me wish that WCW had just let the group go into the sunset instead on insisting on adding odd members and dragging the group out like it was just any other hodgepodge of guys.

The DVD does an incredible job noting the switching of some horsemen from WCW to WWE and back. It does a great job on getting candid with most of the participants, which makes the interviews with Arn Anderson (as most have noted) seem quite odd at times. The Extras & Matches were well chosen in correlation with the documentary.

By themselves, the documentary & the extras/matches would be worth the buy. Together, "Ric Flair & The Four Horsemen" is a must buy.

2/5 Horsemen dvd without Luger???
  by Larry "The Package" Foil (Springfield)
I would like to make a mention, and that I think most of my wrestling colleagues would attest to, is that The Four Horsemen's introduction into the NWA/WCW was comprised of: Ric Flair, Arn Anderson, Tully Blanchard,Ole Anderson, and Lex Luger. This was unmistakenly the best tandem of Horsemen ever assembled. Even though Ole was going through some nagging injuries throughout the mid to later 80's, Ole and Lex were a mainstay of this organization. If Vince McMahon would just get off of his high horse for just a brief point in time and recognize the fact that Lex and Ole should have been included on this DVD. Hey, the guys careers are over Vince. Give them the credit that they deserve.I mean, make the effort Vince and just bury the hatchet, have a good heart to heart talk with these two former greats and let life go on. Even Chris Benoit should have probably gotten some mention in the re-edited DVD also, but due to the extenuating circumstances that happened to Chris & his family, Vince won't let that happen either, even though there are some copies of this DVD that have Chris on it.
There were other really great Horsemen members like Barry Windham, Sid Vicious, and others, but the 1985 formulation was like the founding father of this group. After finding out that Lex & Ole were left off the DVD, I guess I can't blame Lex for jumping to WCW Monday Nitro, after just completing a pay-per-view event the night before in the WWE.


5/5 horseman 4ever
  by Thomas C. King (oakfield ny)
brought me back to my youth. seeing all the great footage in and out of the ring was great

5/5 Diamonds are for ever and so are The Four Horsemen
  by Earl Wilhelm
I loved this DVD. The story of the Horsemen was very well put together. The extras were great especially the video of Dusty Rhodes getting beat down in the parking lot. I've watched this video numerous times. My only complaint is that some of the match selection could have been a lot better, but overal this video is a must have for any old school wrestling fan.

5/5 An incredible story and dvd
  by P. Worsham
WWE does it once again. A great re-living of the best group of wrestlers ever assembled. I was fortunate enough to start watching wrestling again the very week Arn Anderson originally came to Georgia so I lived the whole thing.

I wish Ole would have participated in the commentary but understand that past events and health problems prevented that from happening. I also would have included more matches with a third disc, especially featuring the original four. The one match above all others I wanted to see and was disappointed by its lack of inclusion is the Ole/Arn Anderson vs. Rock and Roll Express match where they originally "broke" Ricky Morton's nose. That match above all others showed just how sadistic Ole and Arn could be in the ring together and show what a great tag team match is all about.

Everything else is all I could ever want or hope for.